Tuesday, August 9, 2011

American Stereotype vs Arab Reality


            Frames are established by authority figures. In our lives, the contexts that we use to interpret different signs are created by the emulation of our role models, primarily our parents, and by careful observation of our immediate surroundings. Growing up in post-9/11 America, most of my peers and I have been exposed to the concept of terrorism through the perception of our mothers, fathers, and teachers, who view terrorists as violent men who possesses weapons, abuse women, and can be classified as middle-eastern Arabs. Throughout life, the notion that terrorists are merciless Arabic villains has been reinforced through the portrayal of this conceptual figure in entertainment media.
            Several ideas seem to repeat in many of the movie excerpts used in Reel Bad Arabs illustrating the potential for the potent influence the use of redundancy in communication can have.  Particularly striking to me was the consistent use of violence to portray Arabic people. In almost all of the films, men are characterized by their brutal dispositions and abusive personalities. The role of women in these movies has evolved from submissive wives to aggressive rebels, who likewise take part in terroristic missions. Even Arab children are portrayed as cruel beings, as seen in Rules of Engagement in which the young girl ultimately shoots American soldiers. Along with this repetition of violent personality traits, I was struck by the way the Arab people were represented by incompetent characters. These types of controversial moments in the film snippets, in which the Arabic individual reveals such stupidity, seems equally noteworthy because they took the stereotype I have accepted of a terrorist exhibiting a violent temperament. I subsequently paired them with the quality of foolishness, further urging me to despise this type of figure.
This scene previously mentioned of the young girl with the weapon resonates in my mind as disturbing and awful, but perhaps even more perturbing is the fact that James Webb, former Secretary of the Navy, wrote the screenplay. I perceive the child as a corrupt Arab who very likely will mature into a terrorist, but it is plausible that I have reacted in the exact way the writer had hoped.  In all honesty, I exhibit the powerful influence that leaders can have over people, thereby enforcing the fact that the repetition of an idea through media can determine the way a population thinks.  This depiction of my own personal connection between the Arab child as the sign and the potential for a terrorist as the object together demonstrates the consequence involved with the American film industry portraying the Arab people in such a manner.  If the leaders want the population of the United States to view Arab people with intense despisement, essentially all they must do is repeatedly present the culture through a condescending perspective. Rulers can condition their people to incorporate certain sociopolitical opinions into their own way of thinking, therefore reinforcing the object of the Arab sign.
              Although I recognized only a mere five movies included in this documentary, I had never before reacted to them with such a critical eye. Before opening my mind to other perspectives, I had always accepted the indexical relationship between and a terrorist and an Arab. Also, I realize that at one point in my life I knew almost every lyric to the Aladdin soundtrack; however, I am certain that I never interpreted them as so derisive.  To be quite honest, I was not cognizant of the discriminatory nature of the Arab character the first times I saw movies such as Back to the Future or The Father of the Bride: Part 2. Subconsciously, I simply accepted the stereotype and moved on, anticipating the hero’s victory in the storyline. Relating primarily to the American figure in the movies I recognized, my previous experience with the specific portrayal of the Arab people we have discussed in class has always been superficial in nature, whereas I have accepted the conceptualized image of a terrorist; I have proven the power of redundant ideas in media.
              Ultimately, this documentary sheds light on the influential potential of popular culture, especially movies. Films, in spite of truth, evidence certain ideas by crafting them into viewable, relatable scenes.  Parts of movies that introduce middle-eastern Arabs with villainous nuances confirm the stereotypical opinions that Americans are conditioned to have. Presenting Arabs as a violent cultural group, accepting them as unchanging over time, and branding the Islam religion with the label of “enemy” cultivate a unified mindset of the American population, as I have already experienced. We begin to scrutinize our surroundings from a young age and continue to monitor what our role models are doing. Celebrities and other prominent figures in the media instigate certain opinions, political as well as racial. In my opinion, pop culture not only shapes comprehension of self and other, but also, it creates these conceptions. We must be aware of the leverage mass media can have over a people and learn from the repercussions of the past. The documentary teaches us to use indexical relationships to establish our own personal frames so that one day we may break away from the conceptualized stereotypes we have been conditioned to accept, resulting in perceptions through which we can humanize all cultures and form opinions based solely on personal experience.

No comments:

Post a Comment